Reciprocity

 
 
 
 

Just in case you need more proof that investing in building stakeholder relationships creates a return on investment, consider for a moment an applicable observation from brain science.

In his thoroughly fascinating book Influence: Science and Practice, University of Arizona professor Robert Cialdini summarizes decades of research on human cognition, identifying six "cognitive shortcuts” that affect human behavior.1 One of these shortcuts may help to explain the power of the stakeholder approach.

In a classic sociology experiment from the 1960’s, a participant was recruited for an ‘art appreciation’ study.  He or she was seated next to a researcher posing as a fellow participant and asked to review some art.  With this ruse in place, the real experiment began.  The researcher, who called himself Joe, nonchalantly excused himself for a few minutes, and returned, empty handed in 1/2 of the cases and with two bottles of Coca-Cola, one for himself and one for the participant, in the other 1/2.  After the ‘art appreciation’ work had been completed, Joe then asked the participant to buy some tickets for a raffle he was running for 25 cents each.

The experiment illustrated what Cialdini has come to call The Reciprocity Rule. When Joe had given the participant a Coke, he sold far more raffle tickets than when he did not.  In fact, people didn’t just reciprocate in-kind, essentially paying him back for the price of the Coke. On average, participants gave Joe five-times more than he had given them.  Here is Robert Cialdini:

According to sociologists and anthropologists, one of the most widespread and basic norms of human culture is embodied in the rule for reciprocation.  The rule requires that one person [or group] try to repay, in kind, what another person [or group] has provided.

By obligating the recipient of an act to repayment in the future, the rule for reciprocation allows one individual to give something to another with confidence that it is not being lost.  This sense of future obligation within the rule makes possible the development of various continuing relationships, transactions, and exchanges that are beneficial to society.  Consequently, all members of the society are trained from childhood to abide by the rule or suffer serious social disapproval.2

In this light, we can get a sense for why creating value for all of an organization’s stakeholders contributes to long-term thriving.  If you help them succeed, they will reciprocate.  Conversely, it also offers a powerful word of caution to those who abuse their stakeholders.

1,2 Cialdini, R. B. (1993). Influence: Science and practice. New York: Harper Collins College Publishers.